Iowa caucuses
The Iowa caucuses are significant political events that mark the beginning of the presidential primary season in the United States, taking place every four years between early January and early February. They are the first contests where voters from Iowa influence the nomination of candidates for the Republican and Democratic parties. The caucus format differs from traditional primaries, as voters engage in public discussions and express their preferences through either secret ballots (Republicans) or group alignments (Democrats). Winners of the Iowa caucuses often gain momentum heading into subsequent contests, particularly the New Hampshire primary, which follows shortly after. However, the predictive value of the Iowa caucuses can be mixed; while they have been more successful for Democratic nominees, fewer Republican winners have gone on to secure their party's nomination. Criticism of the caucuses includes low voter turnout due to time constraints and questions about representativeness, as Iowa’s demographic makeup is less diverse than the national average. The caucuses are a focal point for retail politics, where candidates personally engage with voters, a practice less feasible in larger-scale primaries.
On this Page
Iowa caucuses
Held every four years, the Iowa caucuses are the first contests of the presidential primary season, during which American citizens determine who the eventual nominee for the Republican Party and Democratic Party will be in the general election held in November. The exact date of the Iowa caucuses fluctuates each election cycle, but they occur sometime between early January and early February. As the first contests of the primary season since the 1970s, the Iowa caucuses often set the tone for the rest of the primary season, generating an intense amount of media attention and attracting a significant volume of focus and campaigning from many of the candidates themselves during the summer of the previous year up until the day of the caucuses. The New Hampshire primary immediately follows the Iowa caucuses and typically occurs the following week. The winners of the Iowa caucuses earn a considerable amount of media coverage and the positive support of citizens in Middle America; as a result, achieving victory in the contest provides winners with a certain degree of momentum heading into New Hampshire. Despite the high-profile nature of the Iowa caucuses, however, their record of predicting the eventual nominee of a party is mixed—although nearly all presidential candidates since the 1970s have won either Iowa or New Hampshire during the primary season. Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Texas Senator Ted Cruz won the 2016 Democratic and Republican Iowa caucuses, respectively. In 2020, Secretary of Transportation, Pete Buttigieg, won the Democratic Iowa caucus, with President Joseph Biden winning in 2024 before leaving the race. Donald Trump won the Republican caucuses in 2020 and 2024.
Background
A caucus is quite different from the much more common primary as a political contest. Primaries are straightforward and consist of voters entering their polling place, casting their ballot in private, and then leaving. A caucus operates somewhat differently and is more time-consuming for voters. In 2016, fourteen states featured caucuses, each have their own distinct, specific rules, and the rules of the Iowa caucuses are different for the Republican and Democratic Parties. Registered Republican voters gather at their local precinct (one of 1,681 precincts throughout Iowa) at a designated time, listen to a series of persuasive speeches given by the representatives of various candidates, and then indicate their candidate of choice on a secret ballot. The Democratic caucuses in Iowa also feature persuasive speeches given on behalf of the candidates but require voters to openly and publicly indicate their candidate of choice by gathering in groups aligned with a specific candidate. The number of states using a caucus declined after 2016. In 2024, only a handful of states were still solely using the caucus system instead of a primary election, and other states had both caucuses and primary elections.
A major hallmark of both the Iowa caucuses and subsequent New Hampshire primary is the focus on "retail politics" among the candidates of both major political parties. The phrase "retail politics" is political slang for efforts made by candidates to personally "sell themselves" to voters by meeting with them individually; attending local events, such as the Iowa State Fair, local sporting events, or church with local residents; regularly holding town hall meetings; and visiting all or most of the counties in Iowa and New Hampshire. This tactic contrasts sharply with the much less personal, large-scale method of campaigning, in which candidates attempt to garner votes by simply airing radio and television advertisements and holding occasional rallies with large numbers of spectators. Retail politicking in Iowa and New Hampshire begins almost as soon as a candidate announces that they are entering the presidential race.
Overview
Since 1976, Bill Clinton (in 1992) is the only candidate in either major political party to have won the presidential election after losing both the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary. However, the Republican Iowa caucuses have rarely been an accurate predictor of the eventual Republican presidential nominee. Since 1980, the only winners of the Republican Iowa caucuses who went on to become their party’s nominee have been former Kansas senator Bob Dole (in 1996), former Texas governor George W. Bush (in 2000), and Donald Trump (2020 and 2024). The New Hampshire primary has been a more reliable indicator of the Republican presidential nominee since 1980, with the five winners of that contest becoming the party’s nominee: former California governor Ronald Reagan (1980), former vice president George H. W. Bush (1988), Arizona senator John McCain (2008), former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney (2012), and President Donald Trump (2020 and 2024). By contrast, the Democratic Iowa caucuses have been much more accurate in predicting the party’s presidential nominee. Democratic winners of the Iowa caucuses who became presidential nominees include former Vice-President Walter Mondale (1984), former Vice-President Al Gore (2000), former Massachusetts Senator John Kerry (2004), and former Illinois Senator Barack Obama (2008). As the first ballots cast in the presidential nomination process, the Iowa caucuses serve to narrow the field of candidates in both parties, as several candidates often drop out of the race after faring poorly in the caucus results.
Political pundits, voters, and even some candidates themselves have raised several criticisms regarding the Iowa caucuses. Bill Clinton, the forty-second President of the United States, is one of the biggest critics of the Iowa caucuses. Turnout for caucuses is extremely low compared to primaries due to the fact that caucusing only occurs for a few specific hours and requires voters to be present during those hours in order to participate. This policy contrasts with a primary, in which polls remain open throughout the day, and voters are free to enter whenever a time is convenient for them. Thus, many voters cannot participate in caucuses due to conflicts with work schedules, family commitments, or other competing interests. Another major criticism pertains to the inordinate amount of media coverage and political attention that Iowa and New Hampshire—two of the smaller states in the nation—receive at the expense of other, more heavily populated states, solely on the basis that they always come first and second, respectively, in the presidential primary season. Their citizens are afforded an opportunity to meet and personally get to know candidates in ways that citizens of other states do not since retail politics is simply not possible in primaries and caucuses that occur later on a weekly basis, with several states often holding elections on the same day.
Another common criticism is that Iowa and New Hampshire are two of the least demographically diverse states in the nation and, therefore, are not representative of the American population. Iowa’s population lacks ethnic, racial, and religious diversity. Political comedian Bill Maher has suggested that states with more diverse populations—such as California, Florida, or New York—should vote earlier during the primary season to offset this limitation.
Bibliography
Balz, Dan. "Does Iowa Really Matter? And Should It?" The Washington Post, 31 Jan. 2016, www.washingtonpost.com/politics/does-iowa-really-matter-and-should-it/2016/01/31/22cad600-c83c-11e5-a7b2-5a2f824b02c9‗story.html. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Cramer, Maria. “Besides Iowa, These Are the States With Caucuses.” The New York Times, 13 Feb. 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/02/04/us/politics/what-states-caucus.html. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Jackson, David. "The Iowa Caucuses: An Accident of History." USA Today, 29 Jan. 2016, www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2016/01/29/iowa-caucuses-history-jimmy-carter-julian-zelizer/79426692. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Levy, Adam. "Iowa is Changing its Caucus Rules. Here’s What’s Changed in 2020." CNN, 3 Feb. 2020, edition.cnn.com/2020/01/27/politics/iowa-caucuses-how-they-work/index.html. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Montanaro, Domenico. "How Predictive Are Iowa and New Hampshire?" NPR, 31 Jan. 2016, www.npr.org/2016/01/31/465016222/how-predictive-are-iowa-and-new-hampshire. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Redlawsk, David P., Caroline J. Tolbert, and Todd Donovan. Why Iowa? How Caucuses and Sequential Elections Improve the Presidential Nominating Process. University of Chicago Press, 2011.
Salo, Jackie. "Iowa 2016: What's The Difference Between A Caucus And A Primary Vote?" International Business Times, 1 Feb. 2016, www.ibtimes.com/iowa-2016-whats-difference-between-caucus-primary-vote-2286998. Accessed 6 Jan. 2025.
Skipper, John C. The Iowa Caucuses: First Tests of Presidential Aspiration, 1972–2008. Jefferson: McFarland, 2010.