Good Samaritan laws
Good Samaritan laws are designed to encourage individuals to assist those in emergencies without the fear of legal repercussions, such as being sued for unintentional harm. Originating from a biblical parable, these laws aim to promote a moral obligation to help others in dire situations. Their application varies significantly across different countries and regions; for instance, while many places in Canada have Good Samaritan acts, Quebec imposes a legal duty to assist. In contrast, Germany mandates that citizens provide first aid, while penalizing those who refuse to help. Some nations, however, such as China, discourage assistance due to fears of legal penalties against Good Samaritans.
In the United States, the scope of protection under Good Samaritan laws can be inconsistent, with some states offering immunity only to trained medical professionals. Landmark legislation, like the 911 Good Samaritan laws passed in New Mexico, specifically aims to reduce fatal overdoses by shielding callers and victims from prosecution related to drug use. It is important to note that these laws generally do not protect individuals who act maliciously or recklessly while attempting to help. Overall, Good Samaritan laws reflect a complex interplay between moral responsibilities and legal protections that can influence bystander behavior in emergency situations.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Good Samaritan laws
Good Samaritan laws are enacted to provide immunity from prosecution and to encourage individuals to help others who are dangerously ill, injured, or in another perceived life-threatening situation. The laws allow bystanders to offer help without fear of being sued or blamed for accidental injury or death. In several countries, it is a crime not to come to the aid of someone in dire need. Good Samaritan laws in some US states only protect trained medical personnel from liability. In the early 2000s, legislation was passed in the United States to help reduce the number of fatal overdoses by protecting the caller and the victim from prosecution for possession of drugs or drug paraphernalia and/or for being under the influence.
Overview
Good Samaritan laws take their name from a parable in the New Testament of the Bible. Luke 10:25–37 tells of a man who is robbed, stripped of his clothes, beaten, and left by the side of the road. Several people pass by, look the other way, and do not help. A stranger from the neighboring area of Samaria eventually stops, cleans and bandages the man’s injuries, and provides for his shelter.
Many legislators throughout the world believe in the moral necessity of Good Samaritan laws, which are intended to encourage bystanders to help someone in dire need without fear of legal repercussions due to further injury or the inability to prevent death. Laws vary from country to country and from region to region within a country. Most provinces in Canada, for example, have Good Samaritan acts in place, but Quebec states that its citizens have a legal duty to respond to someone in need. In addition, several European countries criminally punish anyone who refuses to help someone in dire need. Germany requires its citizens to provide first aid to someone in need and does not penalize the individual, regardless whether the first aid worsened the injured person’s condition. China, on the other hand, is known for penalizing its Good Samaritans to the extent that people will often walk by someone in need of help because they fear punishment.
While many US states have some form of Good Samaritan law in place, many others only provide protection from liability to emergency workers or medical professionals who are expected to provide aid at their level of training. In the case of trained emergency or medical workers, if a condition worsens because of negligence, Good Samaritan laws may not protect the individual. Any individual, regardless of their training, who is proven to have acted in a malicious, unruly, or reckless manner is not protected under Good Samaritan laws in most countries.
In 2007, New Mexico was the first US state to pass what became known as 911 Good Samaritan legislation. This new type of Good Samaritan law was developed to help prevent drug overdose deaths that resulted from fear of police involvement. The legislation protects the individual who seeks help (usually through dialing the North American emergency telephone number 911) and the overdose victim from prosecution for drug or drug paraphernalia possession and/or for being under the influence of drugs.
Bibliography
Bartels, Elizabeth C. Volunteer Police in the United States: Programs, Challenges, and Legal Aspects. New York: Springer, 2013. Print.
“China Tries a ‘Good Samaritan’ Law.” Christian Science Monitor. Christian Science Monitor, 29 July 2013. Web. 12 May 2014.
Couig, Mary Pat, and Patricia Watts Kelley, eds. “Good Samaritan Statutes.” Annual Review of Nursing Research. Vol. 30. New York: Springer, 2012. 82–85. Print.
Ratcliffe, James M. The Good Samaritan and the Law. Gloucester: Smith, 1981. Print.
Stanton, Terry. “On Call at 30,000 Feet.” AAOS Now 7.9 (2013): 1–10. Print.
Stewart, Patricia H. “What Does the Law Say to Good Samaritans?” CHEST 143.6 (2013) 1774–83. Print.
Time, Victoria, et al. “Don’t Help Victims of Crime if You Don’t Have the Time: Assessing Support for Good Samaritan Laws.” Journal of Criminal Justice 38.4 (2010): 790–95. Print.
Tracy, Melissa, et al. “Circumstances of Witnessed Drug Overdose in New York City: Implications for Intervention.” Drug and Alcohol Dependence 79 (2005): 181–90. Print.
Weissman, Barry. “Good Samaritan Laws.” Occupational Health & Safety 81.4 (2012): 41. Print.