Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut
"Player Piano" is Kurt Vonnegut's debut novel, classified as dystopian fiction. Set in the fictional city of Ilium after World War III, the narrative depicts a society dominated by an elite class of manager-engineers, while the displaced populace, whose jobs have been automated, struggles for identity and purpose. Central to the story is Paul Proteus, the son of a former Works Manager, who grapples with the pressures of societal advancement and his personal dissatisfaction. The player piano serves as a key symbol of automation, representing the dehumanizing effects of technology that replace human labor. Throughout the novel, Vonnegut explores themes of identity, purpose, and the existential crises faced by those rendered obsolete by progress. As Proteus navigates his internal conflict and the expectations of his wife, he ultimately chooses to embrace human fallibility over the cold efficiency of technology. The narrative culminates in a failed revolution led by Proteus, highlighting his quest for meaning in a world that often equates identity with work. "Player Piano" poignantly critiques the human cost of automation, emphasizing the deep connection between employment and self-worth.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Player Piano by Kurt Vonnegut
First published: 1952
The Work
Player Piano, Kurt Vonnegut’s first novel, belongs to a category referred to as dystopian fiction. Such works depict a future in which scientific advances create a new, nightmarish world. Vonnegut’s setting is the fictional city of Ilium after World War III. Society is run by an elite of manager-engineers. They all live on one side of the river. On the other side of the river live those whose jobs have been taken by automation. They are supported by the state on pensions or in make-work employment. Without jobs or purpose, these displaced persons lack identity and feel that their lives are meaningless.
Paul Proteus is the son of a former Works Manager and seems capable of moving into the highest levels of management himself, but he is troubled by doubts. His wife, Anita, pushes him to advance, but many evenings he slips into old clothes and goes to a bar on the other side of the river. In the bar is a player piano, a key symbol in this novel, as it represents perhaps an early automated replacement of a human.
Increasingly torn between dissatisfaction and pressure to advance, Paul considers the option of buying a farm and opting out of the conflict. Anita rejects that idea. Paul continues to be like his mythical namesake, Proteus, who survived by changing his identity, especially when the company makes him pretend to be a traitor and spy on the rebel Ghost Shirt Society.
Paul is tried as a traitor, and at last forced to choose. He chooses human worth and dignity over the technologically managed society. Paul becomes the Messiah of the Ghost Shirt Society, which stages a nationwide revolution that quickly fails. The novel ends with Proteus marching toward his captors. His revolution has failed, but ironically that validates Proteus’ choice of fallibility as an essential human quality over the dehumanizing infallibility of technology. He at last discovers what he believes in and arrives at a consistent identity for himself.
The novel focuses on Paul Proteus’ search for identity, and the same issue impacts most other characters. Repeatedly Vonnegut suggests identity is closely tied to function or employment. Without work, people question their purpose. Paul’s wife Anita seeks her identity as a woman by following glossy magazines’ suggestions for how a company wife and hostess should behave. Another character gives himself an identity as an expert at watching television with the sound off and guessing what the singer is singing. Player Piano foresees the human cost, not only in lost income but also in loss of self-worth and purpose, that afflict the thousands who are displaced by technology.
Bibliography
Klinkowitz, Jerome, and J. Somer, eds. The Vonnegut Statement. New York: Dell Books, 1973.
Leeds, Marc. The Vonnegut Encyclopedia. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1995.
Merrill, Robert, ed. Critical Essays on Kurt Vonnegut. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1990.
Reed, Peter J. Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell, 1976.