Model Minority
The term "model minority" refers to a demographic group, particularly in the United States, that has achieved notable socioeconomic success despite facing discrimination and hardship. Initially introduced by sociologist William Petersen in 1966, the concept was meant to highlight groups like Jewish Americans and Asian Americans, who were seen as examples of successful assimilation into the dominant culture. While the model minority label is often associated with high educational attainment and economic stability, it has been criticized for promoting oversimplified stereotypes and ignoring the diverse experiences within these communities.
Critics argue that the model minority myth can perpetuate harmful narratives, suggesting that certain groups, like Asian Americans, lack the political engagement or emotional drive to resist discrimination, thereby reinforcing notions of passivity. Furthermore, the idealization of these groups can lead to excessive pressure on individuals to conform to high expectations, which might contribute to mental health issues, including anxiety and depression. The model minority framework has also been linked to the marginalization of those who do not fit the stereotype, creating a divide within communities and labeling some as "forever foreigners." Overall, the model minority concept remains a complex and contentious topic, reflecting the challenges of racial identity and assimilation in contemporary society.
On this Page
Subject Terms
Model Minority
Model minority is a pop sociology term used to describe an ethnic, racial, or religious minority group that, overcoming discrimination and economic hardship, has achieved measurable socioeconomic success in the process of assimilating into the dominant culture. First proposed by sociologist William Petersen in a 1966 New York Times Magazine article during the height of the civil rights movement as a paradigm for ranking minority group status using, among other parameters, education success, income levels, commitment to employment, and family stability profiles. The concept of the model minority is most frequently applied in the United States to the Jewish American community, the Asian American community, and first-generation African communities. The term has also been widely criticized for perpetuating stereotypes and simplifying the difficult process of assimilation.
Overview
Even when Petersen first proposed the idea of a model minority, many sociopolitical commentators saw in the idea a coded criticism leveled by embattled White America against the upheaval over African American civil rights being waged at the time. By proposing that “model” minority groups worked with, rather than against, the dominant White cultural community, the model minority paradigm reinforced conformity and cooperation as key to long-term success. This designated other vocal, proactive minority groups as problematic; that is, those that used confrontation and agitation to promote their agendas, which included Black and Hispanic Americans.
From the beginning, the Asian American community—a diverse group comprised of Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Indian, Filipino, Vietnamese, and other immigrants—was designated in the popular press and academic forums as the most model minority, based on college graduation rates and advanced degrees, community status, career advancement, and income levels. In fact, as a group, Asian American success exceeded the White majority average. The model minority theory argued that the Asian American community achieved that success without violence, political agitation, or confrontation. That designation, however, and the data used to defend it was not without its negative effects. The implication was that despite vicious and widespread discrimination, Asian Americans lacked the political drive or the emotional passion to sustain resistance; they were stereotyped as passive and cooperative, more interested in getting by or getting along.
As critics point out, many ethnic groups within the umbrella of Asian Americans still struggle with economic hardship and lack of education opportunities. By using the data on Asian American education success, the model minority paradigm pressures those children to overachieve and excel in the classroom, holding them to a higher standard under the assumption they are all smart and naturally gifted. As adults, the assumption follows that Asian Americans will be industrious, highly successful, and will work without complaint. As individuals internalize this stereotype, they may feel like an imposter in their career or social life, leading to interpersonal shame and higher rates of stress, insomnia, depression, anxiety, suicidality, or other mental health conditions. These repercussions of the model minority myth are cited as one of the likely causes of the disproportionately high rate of suicide among Asian Americans.
Twenty-first-century sociologists see the model minority paradigm as a way to assess minority status as a starting point in understanding the diversity of minority groups and the pressures of assimilation. Overall, it is understood that stereotypes like model minorities are counterproductive to Asian American assimilation, leading to what some sociologists call “forever foreigners.” Asian Americans who do not fit the stereotype of the model minority are at risk of being ostracized from society because they do not identify with their ethnic group of origin or mainstream American culture.
Bibliography
Chou, Rosalind S., and Joe R. Feagin. The Myth of the Model Minority: Asian Americans Facing Racism. 2nd ed., Paradigm, 2016.
Duong, Gary. "You're Called a 'Model Minority' as an Asian American—Until They Decide You Aren't." NPR, 30 May 2022, www.npr.org/2022/05/30/1101790205/as-an-asian-american-youre-called-a-model-minority-until-they-decide-you-arent. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
Guofang, Li, and Lihshing Wang, eds. Model Minority Myth Revisited: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Demystifying Asian American Education Experiences. Information Age, 2008.
Hartlep, Nicholas Daniel. The Model Minority Stereotype: Demystifying Asian American Success. 2nd ed., Information Age Publishing, Inc., 2021.
Kramer, Erik Mark. The Emerging Monoculture: Assimilation and the “Model Minority.” Greenwood, 2003.
Kang, Jatinder. British Indian Model Minority Pupils’ Schooling Experiences: Attitudes, Attainment, and Strategies. Routledge, 2024.
Lee, Stacey. Unraveling the “Model Minority” Stereotype: Listening to Asian American Youth. Teachers College P, 2009.
Petersen, William. Ethnicity Counts. Transaction, 2012.
Petersen, William. “Success Story: Japanese American Style.” New York Times, 9 Jan. 1966, www.nytimes.com/1966/01/09/archives/success-story-japaneseamerican-style-success-story-japaneseamerican.html. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
Ruiz, Neil G., Carolyne Im, and Ziyao Tian. "Asian Americans and the ‘Model Minority’ Stereotype." PewResearch, 30 Nov. 2023, www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2023/11/30/asian-americans-and-the-model-minority-stereotype. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
Wei, Meifen, et al. “Impostor Feelings and Psychological Distress among Asian Americans: Interpersonal Shame and Self-Compassion.” The Counseling Psychologist, vol. 48, no. 3, 2020, pp. 432–58, doi.org/10.1177/0011000019891992. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
Whaley, Arthur L., and La Tonya Noel. “Academic Achievement and Behavioral Health among Asian American and African American Adolescents: Testing the Model Minority and Inferior Minority Assumptions.” Social Psychology of Education, vol. 16, no. 1, 2013, pp. 23–43. doi:10.1007/s11218-012-9206-2. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.
Zhang, Qin. “Asian Americans beyond the Model Minority Stereotype: The Nerdy and the Left Out.” Journal of International and Intercultural Communication, vol. 3, no. 1, 2010, pp. 20–37, doi.org/10.1080/17513050903428109. Accessed 23 Dec. 2024.